When one draws, there are those (who do not draw) who say, “WOWthatisSOgood” and many other complimentary gushing things. We who draw or paint need this admiration. It feels good, it encourages us to continue, it gives us confidence. What it does not do is help us to improve. We have to tell each other the truth if we are to make our art be the best that it can be. In my drawing classes, it is imperative that we are honest with one another. Those that know how to draw have a wealth of experience to offer one another. It has to be done carefully, because sometimes discouragement can set in. “The bark on your tree looks exactly right, but the leaves are looking a bit like cat fur” – that is the kind of feedback often heard. And even that isn’t quite enough. So my leaves look furry – HOW do I make them not look so feline-ish? (That is where the teacher is supposed to have answers.) My students get the chance to be honest with me. Most of my work gets shown to my students so they can have a go at it. They are just as honest with me as I am with them (and we DO try to be kind in our criticism). I listen carefully to what each one says and consider each suggestion and usually do what they tell me. (Perhaps I should be paying them for lessons!) I actually enjoy hearing them tell me the same things that I have told them, because it confirms for me that they are learning!
I drew the river and while showing it to a class, one girl said, “Can I say something?” I said, “PLEASE do!”, while remembering that she is a guide on river rafting trips. She gave me a ton of little tips about how the water should look as it flows past rocks. Brought to mind something Jack White wrote – “If you don’t know your subject, someone else will.” Thank you, HJ! (This is not the picture – I didn’t photograph that other one and it is sold, as is this one.)
